By Kim Lowe and Matt Norris
President Obama's proposal to make community college free was another blow to for-profit higher education providers., according to a recent Forbes article that analyzed the for-profit sector's deep troubles, and a further decline in stock prices after the announcement. In Minnesota, the state Senate's DFL majority leadership also recently proposed free tuition for community college.
There is no other way to say it; reconciling return-on-shareholder investment with providing affordable, cost-effective education to middle- and low-income students challenges the for-profit business model. As educational institutions, for-profit education providers will always be subject to criticism when held up against their public and nonprofit brethren. How can a profit-making endeavor hold its head high against either a land grant state-funded college or a university founded by nuns or priests? This challenge becomes even harder given that for-profit schools tend to serve a population less able to access elite non-profit higher education providers.
Here's a possible solution. Recently Rasmussen College -- a regionally accredited private college (a for-profit enterprise owned by private investors) -- issued a press release celebrating its first anniversary as a Public Benefit Corporation. Rasmussen is one of the largest for-profit colleges operating in Minnesota. And by the way, a recent report from the state's Office of Higher Education suggests that Minnesota's for-profit colleges compare favorably on some key outcomes to their public competitors.
It remains to be seen whether the Public Benefit Corporation banner will enable Rasmussen and other Minnesota for-profits to survive and prosper, but we congratulate Rasmussen for taking this innovative course. The chartered benefit corporation model allows a for-profit school to legitimately say that student outcomes and success are at least as important as shareholder return on investment.
The Public Benefit Corporation form is a relatively new form of organizational structure that allows a for-profit enterprise to legally embrace and pursue a social purpose that is at least co-equal with shareholder return on investment. Twenty-seven states, including Minnesota, whose law took effect January 1, 2015, have adopted legislation permitting benefit corporations, which have been embraced as part of a new wave of social entrepreneurship both in Minnesota and across the country.
As proponents who helped draft this legislation, and as explainers of it, we encourage other colleges and entrpreneurs with ideas for socially beneficial enterprises to consider the advantages of public benefit corporation status and to check out other sources on the subject.
Kim Lowe, a shareholder at Fredrikson & Byron P.A., chairs the ABA Business Law Section’s Task Force on Social Ventures, leads Fredrikson’s nonprofit organizations practice group, Start Up and Rapid Growth Enterprises practice group and the newly formed Social Entrepreneur practice group. Ms. Lowe chaired the Minnesota Public Benefit Corporation Act Drafting Committee. Matt Norris, J.D., is a graduate of the University of Minnesota Law School and was a member of the Minnesota Public Benefit Corporation Act Drafting Committee. Lowe also is a member of the Growth & Justice Board of Directors.
In previous blogs, I wrote about the University of Minnesota and its history of an expectation of transparency and a framework of accountability. In Minnesota, the University follows the same public access to information laws as other government entities, namely the Data Practices Act and the Open Meeting Law, and has had an expectation of accountability to the State Legislature ever since its founding in 1851. That’s 162 years to practice ... Read More
Minnesotans take openness in government and public records for granted. This has been a key principle of our state's democratic process since statehood in 1858, and often improved upon, and greatly expanded under "sunshine laws'' in the 1970s. In contrast, the Access to Public Information Law (LAIP) in El Salvador is only two years old.. The Law includes a 25- point list and definition of wha... Read More
Greetings from El Salvador! To paraphrase and expand on a theme we often heard from Sen. Paul Wellstone, we all do better when all the world’s nations improve their democracies and when more people benefit from more responsive and accountable governments. I’m here on a professional leadership exchange program funded by the U.S. Department of State and implemented by Partners of the Americas. The Legislative Fellows exchange pro... Read More
Steve Berg's excellent op-ed that rethinks our Twin Cities brand and a similar essay published last week by Jay Walljasper and sponsored by the McKnight Foundation should inspire plenty of creative feedback from us Twin Cities and Minnesota enthusiasts. Both articles feed on the outstanding work done so far by Greater MSP, a new organization focused on more effective marketing of the Twin Cities metropolitan are... Read More
The Star Tribune's fine piece summarizing the remarkable contributions of the late Douglas Dayton contains this passage. Dayton and his brothers established one of the first corporate-giving programs in Minnesota and Dayton said he took great joy in researching and investing in effective nonprofits. He said donating money was more satisfying than making it.“You bet your life it is,” Dayton said. “After a... Read More
Web Development by Creative Arc, a Minneapolis Web Design firm.